Forensic Scientist Claims Jeffrey Epstein Was Murdered After Yearlong Autopsy Review

LONDON. A forensic scientist who spent a year inside Jeffrey Epstein’s complete autopsy file said Monday evening that the injuries point to homicide, not the suicide by hanging that New York City ruled in 2019. The claim landed at Middle Temple, one of London’s historic legal societies, and it comes from an expert who has testified in some of America’s highest-profile death-in-custody cases.

Michael Freeman, editor-in-chief of the Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine with academic appointments at Maastricht University Medical Center in the Netherlands and Oregon Health and Science University, reviewed the file and photographs at the invitation of Epstein’s brother, Mark. He says the work was independent and unpaid. He has served as a cause-of-death expert to state attorneys general in police-custody cases and testified in the George Floyd case, according to IBTimes.

His reading of the photographs starts with the ligature mark. “Wait a minute, that doesn’t look like a hanging mark,” Freeman recalled thinking when he first saw the autopsy photo, in an account published by the New York Times. The mark was deep, ragged and branched into a Y-shape on one side rather than forming the smooth, upward-sloping line of a textbook hanging, and he identifies a second, lower mark at a different angle that a single ligature cannot explain.

From there his case builds outward. He reads marks above the ligature line as possible fingernail impressions, “consistent with strangulation, particularly from behind,” with the victim trying to pull the ligature away, as he told the BBC. A deep haemorrhage in the left shoulder muscle, an abrasion at the base of the neck and facial injuries complete what he calls the spectrum. “The injuries and the way the body was found don’t match up,” he said. “There’s only one remaining explanation then, and that is that the death was as a result of a homicide.”

Epstein, 66, was found dead in his cell at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in lower Manhattan on the morning of August 10, 2019, while awaiting trial on federal sex-trafficking charges. The city’s Office of Chief Medical Examiner ruled the death a hanging and the manner suicide, an autopsy performed the next day by Dr. Kristin Roman. The office said Tuesday it stands by that determination, the New York Post reported.

The official side carries its own weight. Roman told Justice Department investigators the injuries were more consistent with hanging than homicidal strangulation and that there were no defensive wounds of the kind seen in strangulation victims. Dr. Barbara Sampson, the chief medical examiner at the time, has said: “I stand firmly behind our determination of the cause and manner of death for Mr. Epstein,” according to the BBC.

Freeman worked with Anders Eriksson, a Umea University forensic pathologist, and Itiel Dror, a cognitive neuroscientist who studies how bias distorts forensic conclusions. The team tested whether a hanging could reproduce the injuries, building three-dimensional computer models from the autopsy photographs, Epstein’s physique and the account of the officer who found the body. They concluded strangulation from behind with a narrow, knotted fabric ligature fits better, with the same ligature then used to suspend the body from the bunk.

He is candid about the limits. Asked who might have killed Epstein if his reading is right, Freeman told the BBC he had “no idea” and that identifying anyone played no part in his work. Challenged on whether his conclusions veer into conspiracy theory, he answered: “If you think I’m still a conspiracy theorist because I’m looking at something that looks like a strangulation and say, I think it is a strangulation and I don’t think it could be a hanging, show me where I got it wrong.”

The finding has not cleared peer review. Freeman has said an academic journal rejected the paper because reviewers considered it inappropriate to challenge a medical examiner’s conclusions in print, and he published the files himself after the London presentation, as LBC reported. Other pathologists who reviewed the photographs for the Times split the difference, with some calling the neck mark atypical for hanging and others saying the images could still fit suicide, cautioning that injuries alone cannot establish what happened.

The institutional record around the death is a mess regardless of manner. A June 2023 Justice Department inspector general report documented staffing shortages, missed security checks and failures to follow procedure at the jail, and the FBI reaffirmed suicide in July 2025 after reviewing surveillance footage that it said showed no one entered the relevant tier between about 10:40 p.m. on August 9 and 6:30 a.m. on August 10, while noting the review could not establish every camera was working. Hypefresh covered the Justice Department’s release of the jail video and Representative Nancy Mace’s public doubts about the suicide finding when each surfaced.

The loudest early reactions have come from familiar quarters. Mark Epstein has long maintained his brother was murdered, and British tabloid coverage framed the presentation as the brother demanding a murder probe, while a lawyer for Epstein’s victims called for an independent examination of the new claims, the Mirror reported. The claim also pulls figures tied to Epstein back into the conversation, from the convicted associates of his network to names like Bill Gates, who has called his own friendship with Epstein a mistake.

What Freeman has produced is a reinterpretation of existing records, not a new examination of the body, and no official finding has changed. The medical examiner’s ruling stands. The FBI’s conclusion stands. What changed this week is that a credentialed specialist put his name to the murder reading in public, published the underlying files for anyone to check, and dared reviewers to find the error. The answers owed to survivors, as the victims’ lawyer put it, should rest on evidence rather than unresolved questions.

Latest Posts

[democracy id="16"] [wp-shopify type="products" limit="5"]