A greasy blue envelope sitting in a Plantation, Florida, driveway turned a routine end to the workday into something far more unsettling on August 14, 2025.
The woman whose identity was held back in the court documents recognized the strange handwriting and oily nature immediately. The envelope contained a greeting card covered in brown liquid that she recognized immediately as peanut butter. She threw the envelope down, rushed into the house, and washed her hands. Even after washing, however, hives developed on both arms and the tingling sensation lasted for six hours as reported in the Plantation Police probable cause affidavit.
She has an extreme and potentially fatal allergy to peanuts. According to police, even minimal exposure can cause such a reaction. The medical history, as mentioned in the Plantation Police probable cause affidavit, established the risk.
Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., 68, of Plantation, is the man police say is responsible. Investigators allege he knew the woman for roughly 20 years as the longtime best friend of his ex-wife. The couples socialized often, including dinners where she openly warned restaurant staff about peanuts, peanut oil, and cross-contamination. Police say he “absolutely” understood the danger.
The separation was also highly controversial. Based on the affidavit, it appears that Cancellare was chiefly responsible for causing the breakdown of the relationship. The witnesses told the authorities that he threatened her in their common social circles with hurting her. Their last meeting together in person was years back when she served as an observer while dividing their assets physically.
The envelope carried two Forever stamps. Investigators worked with a U.S. Postal Inspector and traced the stamps to a self-service USPS kiosk in nearby Davie on August 8, 2025. The purchase was made with a Visa card in Cancellare’s name. Kiosk surveillance captured the buyer. When shown the image, the victim and other acquaintances immediately identified him. Police say he wore sunglasses and used a fictitious sender name“Goergina Sawals”plus a false return address. The envelope was processed through a Miami facility the day before it arrived.
Plantation police arrested Cancellare at his home on November 13, 2026. He was charged with aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence exposing another person to harm. Bond was set at $20,000; he has posted it. The case remains pending. These are allegations drawn from the arrest affidavit and have not been proven in court.
The unique thing about this case is that it involves the use of an ordinary food product against a medical weakness.


